Summary
In Pennsylvania, a seller does not automatically have to pay for every repair identified during a home inspection. If you are buying or selling a home, who pays usually depends on the agreement of sale, the inspection contingency, the condition identified, and what both sides negotiate before the applicable deadline.
If you are the buyer, your contract may allow you to request repairs, ask for a seller credit or purchase-price adjustment, accept the property in its current condition, request further evaluation, or terminate the agreement when the contract gives you that right. If you are the seller, you may be able to accept a request, reject it, or propose another solution, subject to the written agreement and any other legal obligations that apply.
Gibson & Perkins, PC helps buyers and sellers in Media, Pennsylvania, Delaware County, and nearby areas review inspection findings, disclosure issues, and contract terms before closing.
Key Point: A home inspection report identifies property conditions. Your agreement of sale determines which contract options you can use after the inspection.
The Home Inspection Report Does Not Automatically Create a Repair Obligation
A Pennsylvania home inspection is intended to help evaluate the overall condition of a dwelling based on the visible and apparent condition of the structure and its components on the inspection date. The report must describe the scope of the inspection and identify material defects observed by the inspector.
Pennsylvania law defines a material defect as a problem with residential real property, or a portion of it, that has a significant adverse impact on the value of the property or creates an unreasonable risk to people on the property. The law also states that a structural element, system, or subsystem being near, at, or beyond the end of its normal useful life is not, by itself, a material defect.
That distinction can affect your repair negotiations. An inspector may report that a roof, furnace, water heater, air-conditioning system, or electrical component is old. Age can affect your decision as a buyer, but age alone does not automatically require the seller to replace that item before closing.
A home inspection report may also recommend evaluation by an appropriate expert when a condition needs more investigation. For example:
- Visible foundation movement may call for evaluation by a structural engineer or another qualified professional.
- Moisture may require further investigation to determine whether the source involves grading, drainage, plumbing, roofing, or the foundation.
- An electrical condition may call for review by a qualified electrician.
After you receive the report, compare the findings with the rights and deadlines in your agreement of sale.
Professionalism is the Word
I highly Recommend Gibson & Perkins. I have used their services for approximately 6 years now and been through a few cases together with very positive outcomes. Personally, I have used Paul Fellman and Walter Timby on those occasions. Both, as a team & separately these Attorneys were wonderful to work with and easily accessible to reach if I had any questions. Professionalism is the word that comes to mind to describe the firm, as a whole. Always completely prepared for any surprises that may pop up during a trial. They were well versed on all pertinent info pertaining to each case. As I client, I always felt I was an integral part of the team, not an after-thought, that had to be brought up to speed a half hour before the trial started. I could not recommend this firm and Mr. Fellman and Mr. Timby any higher.Very Satisfied
I hired Paul Fellman after speeking to several different lawyers from different law firms because he was the most sincere. Paul did an excellent job on my landlord tenant issue I had on my rental property. He was there for me from the beginning to the end of the whole ordeal. I was very satisfied and I highly recommend him and his firm.
The Agreement of Sale Usually Controls What Happens Next
Your agreement of sale is central to deciding what you can do after an inspection.
Pennsylvania law addresses provisions in an agreement of transfer that give a buyer the right to obtain a home inspection report and set out the consequences, if any, that follow from the inspection. Your specific rights depend on the language of the contract you signed.
If your agreement contains an inspection contingency, review the inspection period, notice requirements, deadlines, and available options. Depending on the contract, you may be able to:
- Accept the property in its current condition.
- Request specific repairs.
- Ask for a seller credit toward permitted closing costs or future work, subject to lender and settlement requirements.
- Seek a reduction in the purchase price.
- Request additional evaluation of a suspected condition.
- Terminate the transaction if the contingency permits termination and you follow the required procedure.
A repair request does not automatically require the seller to agree. If you are the seller, you may accept the request, reject it, or offer another solution if the contract allows that response.
For more information about buyer protections in an agreement of sale, visit:
https://www.gibperk.com/how-agreement-of-sales-protects-the-buyer/
For more information about issues that may arise during a real estate transaction, visit:
https://www.gibperk.com/real-estate-transaction-issues/
Common Ways Buyers and Sellers Resolve Inspection Problems
Many inspection issues are resolved through negotiation. The right approach depends on the condition, the contract, the timing, financing requirements, and what each side is willing to accept.
Seller Completes the Repair Before Closing
The seller may agree to complete a specific repair before settlement. This option may work when the condition is clearly identified and enough time remains to complete the work.
A written agreement should state what work must be performed, who may perform it, when it must be finished, and what documentation must be provided.
Seller Provides a Credit
You may prefer a seller credit if you want to choose the contractor and control the work after you take ownership. Before agreeing to a credit, verify that the amount and structure comply with your loan program, lender requirements, and settlement rules.
Purchase Price Is Adjusted
You and the seller may agree to reduce the purchase price. This approach can be useful when you are willing to accept responsibility for the condition after closing but want the negotiated price to reflect that condition.
Buyer Accepts the Property in Its Current Condition
You may decide to proceed without a repair, credit, or price reduction. The condition may be minor, reflected in the negotiated price, or less significant than other terms of the transaction.
What Happens if the Seller Refuses to Make Repairs?
If the seller rejects your repair request, review the inspection contingency before deciding what to do.
While the contingency remains open, your agreement may allow you to:
- Accept the seller's position and proceed with the purchase.
- Revise the repair request.
- Negotiate a credit or purchase-price adjustment.
- Request further evaluation if the contract allows it.
- Terminate the agreement if the contract provides that right and you follow the required procedure.
Pay close attention to deadlines. Do not assume that submitting a repair request extends the inspection period or preserves a right to terminate the agreement.
If the inspection identifies a condition that requires a contractor estimate, engineer review, electrician evaluation, plumbing inspection, or another specialist, you may need enough time within the contingency period to obtain that information.
If you are the seller, review the agreement before promising repairs or agreeing to credits. A written repair commitment can create disputes about the scope of work, contractor qualifications, completion dates, permits, invoices, warranties, or what happens if the work is not finished before settlement.
Seller Disclosure Duties Are Separate From Repair Negotiations
Pennsylvania seller disclosure requirements address a different issue from who pays for inspection repairs.
For residential transfers covered by Pennsylvania's Real Estate Seller Disclosure Law, the seller must disclose known material defects through the required property disclosure statement. The signed and dated disclosure generally must be delivered to the buyer before the buyer and seller sign an agreement of transfer.
A disclosure does not automatically mean that the seller has agreed to repair the disclosed condition.
For example, a seller may disclose an older roof, prior basement water intrusion, or past plumbing work. That disclosure provides information to you as the buyer, but it does not automatically create a promise that the seller will pay for future repairs.
Pennsylvania law also states that a seller is not required to make a specific investigation or inquiry solely to complete the property disclosure statement. The seller may not knowingly make false, deceptive, or misleading representations and may not fail to disclose a known material defect. If previously disclosed information becomes inaccurate before final settlement because of a later act, occurrence, or agreement, the seller must notify the buyer of the inaccuracy.
An inspection issue and a disclosure issue can arise from the same condition, but they are not the same legal question. If an inspection appears to reveal a serious condition that conflicts with the seller's disclosure statement, consider having the contract, disclosure, and inspection report reviewed before you make a final decision.
Three Examples of How Repair Responsibility Can Play Out
An Older Roof With No Active Leak
Suppose your inspector reports that the roof is near the end of its expected useful life but does not identify an active leak or another material defect.
You may ask the seller to replace the roof. The seller may reject that request. You can still negotiate a credit or purchase-price adjustment if both sides agree, but the age of the roof alone does not automatically create a seller-funded replacement obligation. Pennsylvania's definition of a material defect states that being near, at, or beyond normal useful life is not, by itself, a material defect.
Active Basement Moisture
Suppose your inspection reveals fresh basement moisture, staining, and signs of recent water intrusion.
Before negotiating a repair amount, you may request further evaluation to identify the source. The cause could involve grading, gutters, drainage, plumbing, roofing, the foundation, or another condition.
After you have better information about the cause and scope, you and the seller may negotiate repairs, a credit, a price adjustment, or another response allowed by the agreement.
Electrical Safety Concern
Suppose your inspector identifies an electrical condition that may create a safety concern and recommends evaluation by a qualified electrician.
You and the seller may agree that an electrician will evaluate the condition and that the seller will complete specified work before closing. You may also negotiate a different arrangement after you receive the electrician's findings.
The inspection report gives you information about the condition. It does not function as an automatic invoice that one party must pay.
What Should Be Included in a Written Repair Agreement?
If you and the other party reach an agreement about inspection repairs, put the terms in writing with enough detail to reduce later disagreements.
A statement such as "seller will fix electrical problem" may leave both sides with different expectations.
A written repair agreement may address:
- The exact condition that must be repaired.
- Whether a licensed or otherwise qualified contractor must perform the work.
- Whether permits are required.
- The deadline for completion.
- Whether receipts, invoices, warranties, permits, photographs, or reports must be provided.
- Whether the buyer may reinspect the completed work.
- What happens if the work cannot be completed before closing.
- Whether a credit or another financial adjustment will replace the repair.
Your final walkthrough can help you confirm that agreed work appears complete and that no new visible condition has arisen. For structural, technical, or concealed conditions, a professional reinspection may provide more useful information than a general visual walkthrough.
Why Legal Review Can Matter Before Closing
An inspection disagreement can become a contract dispute when the parties disagree about what the agreement requires.
The issue may involve more than whether a cracked wall, old roof, moisture condition, electrical problem, or plumbing defect exists. You may need to determine:
- What the agreement of sale requires.
- Whether proper notice was given.
- Whether an inspection deadline has expired.
- Whether the buyer still has a termination right.
- Whether a proposed credit is permitted by the transaction terms and financing.
- Whether the seller's disclosure accurately addressed the condition.
- Whether a proposed amendment changes other rights under the agreement.
A real estate attorney can review the agreement of sale, inspection report, repair request, disclosure statement, and proposed amendment together. That review can help you understand the written options before you sign a document that changes the transaction.
For information about real estate representation in Media, Pennsylvania, visit:
https://www.gibperk.com/real-estate-attorneys-in-media-pa/
Speak With a Media Real Estate Attorney About an Inspection Dispute
If your home inspection has uncovered a serious condition and you and the other party disagree about repairs, credits, disclosure duties, or closing terms, Gibson & Perkins, PC can review the transaction and explain the options that may apply under the written agreement and Pennsylvania law.
The firm's Media real estate team handles real estate sales contracts, transaction matters, and property disputes for clients in Delaware County, Pennsylvania, and nearby areas.
Call (610) 557-1977 or visit:
https://www.gibperk.com/contact/
This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Consult an attorney about your specific situation.
